Citizendia

See also: Affirmative action in the United States, Reservation in India, and Numerus clausus

The term affirmative action describes policies aimed at a historically socio-politically non-dominant group (typically, minority men or women of all races) intended to promote access to education or employment. Affirmative action in the United States is intended to promote access to education employment or housing among certain designated groups (typically Minorities and Women Reservation in Indian law is a form of Affirmative action whereby a percentage of seats are reserved in the public sector units union and state civil services Numerus clausus ("closed number" in Latin) is one of many methods used to limit the number of Students who may study at a University Education encompasses both the Teaching and Learning of Knowledge, proper conduct, and technical competency Employment is a Contract between two parties, one being the employer and the other being the employee. Motivation for affirmative action is a desire to redress the effects of past and current discrimination that is regarded as unfair. Unlike most discrimination policies discrimination between, which is the discernment of qualities and recognition of the differences focused here discrimination against is It also serves to encourage public institutions such as universities, hospitals and police forces to be more representative of the population[1]. A university is an institution of Higher education and Research, which grants Academic degrees in a variety of subjects A hospital is an institution for Health care providing treatment by specialised staff and equipment and often but not always providing for Police are agents or agencies usually of the executive, empowered to enforce the law and to effect public and social order through the legitimatized use of force

This is commonly achieved through targeted recruitment programs aimed at applicants from socio-politically disadvantaged groups. Recruitment refers to the process of sourcing screening and selecting people for a job at an Organization or firm or for a vacancy in a volunteer-based organization In some cases affirmative action involves giving preferential treatment to these groups. [2] Opponents of affirmative action policies argue that they are based on collectivism and merely another equal form of discrimination because they can result in qualified applicants being denied entry to higher education or employment because they belong to a particular social group (usually the historically socio-politically dominant group; typically majority races and men, regardless of social standing or financial need. Collectivism is a term used to describe any moral political or social outlook that stresses human Interdependence and the importance of a Collective, rather than Unlike most discrimination policies discrimination between, which is the discernment of qualities and recognition of the differences focused here discrimination against is Higher education is Education that is provided by universities, vocational universities, Community colleges Liberal arts colleges Employment is a Contract between two parties, one being the employer and the other being the employee. ) They also argue that preferential treatment should be based upon current social and economical standing, not that of one's ancestors. Some opponents say affirmative action devalues the accomplishments of people who are chosen because of the social group they belong to rather than their qualifications. [3]

Contents

Opponents

Some opponents of affirmative action call it reverse discrimination because affirmative action requires the very discrimination it is seeking to eliminate in order to work. This contradiction makes affirmative action counter-productive. It promotes prejudice by increasing resentment toward those who are the beneficiaries of affirmative action from those who have been adversely affected by the policy (such as poor white). (Read Thomas Sowell's Affirmative Action Around The World and Basic and Applied Economics) It also causes unprepared applicants to be accepted in highly demanding educational institutions or jobs which result in eventual failure. Thomas Sowell (born June 30, 1930) is an American Economist, social commentator and author of dozens of books (See, for example, Richard Sander's study of affirmative action in Law School, bar exam and eventual performance at law firms). Lastly, by lowering the bar, it denies those who strive for excellence on their own merit the sense of real achievement. (See, for example, Clarence Thomas' "My Grandfather's Son: A Memoir". Clarence Thomas (born June 23, 1948) is an American Jurist. He has been serving as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United ) Some argue that affirmative action itself has some merit when it is targeted to true cause of social deprivation such as poverty while race, ethnicity or gender based affirmative action is misguided. [3]

Some opponents claim that affirmative action is not necessary when looking at how past groups that suffered from extensive oppression like Asian, Jewish, Arab, Irish, Eastern European and Southern European Americans, all of whom are groups of people that were also discriminated against within society in the past and never received any benefits from an affirmative action system and have (they claim) done perfectly fine if not better than average in American society today. Oppression is the act of using power to empower and/or privilege a group at the expense of disempowering marginalizing silencing and subordinating another group Asian Americans are Americans of Asian ancestry. They include sub-ethnic groups such as Chinese Americans Filipino Americans Indian American Jews, or Jewish Americans An Arab American is a United States citizen or resident of Arab cultural and linguistic heritage and/or Identity whose ancestry traces back to any of various Irish Americans (Gael-Mheiriceánach are citizens of the United States who can claim ancestry originating in Ireland. Eastern Europe is a general term that refers to the Geopolitical region encompassing the easternmost part of the European continent. The term Southern Europe can have four definitions geographical political climatic phytogeographic A study has noted that on some campuses, such as the University of California, Berkeley where affirmative action was abolished by Proposition 209, Asian American students, who already face discrimination on college campuses, would be the predominant victims of a return to race-conscious admissions. The University of California Berkeley (also referred to as Cal, Berkeley and UC Berkeley) is a major research university located in Berkeley Proposition 209 was a 1996 California ballot proposition which amended the state constitution to prohibit public institutions from considering [4]. Efforts to repeal Proposition 209 and limit the number of Asians on campus resemble the anti-semitic Numerus Clauses once utilized by colleges and universities to reduce the number of Jews. Proposition 209 was a 1996 California ballot proposition which amended the state constitution to prohibit public institutions from considering Asian Americans are Americans of Asian ancestry. They include sub-ethnic groups such as Chinese Americans Filipino Americans Indian American Jews, or Jewish Americans

Notable opponents include Ward Connerly of the American Civil Rights Institute, who has promoted and won a series of ballot initiatives in the states of California (California Proposition 209 (1996)), Washington (1998 - I-200), and Michigan (the Michigan Civil Rights Initiative - MCRI, or Proposal 2, 2006). Wardell Anthony Connerly (born June 15, 1939) is an African-American political Activist, businessman and former University of California Proposition 209 was a 1996 California ballot proposition which amended the state constitution to prohibit public institutions from considering The Michigan Civil Rights Initiative ( MCRI) or Proposal 2 (Michigan 06-2 was a Ballot initiative in the U California's initiative was co-authored by academics Tom Wood and Glynn Custred in the mid-1990s and was taken up by Connerly after he was appointed in 1994 by Governor Pete Wilson to the University of California Board of Regents. Each of the ballot initiatives have won, and Connerly plans what he calls a "Super-Tuesday" of five additional states in 2008.

Notable academicians such as Professor Carl Cohen of the University of Michigan, who was a supporter of Michigan's Proposal 2, have argued that the term "affirmative action" should be defined differently than "race preference," and that while socio-economically based or anti-discrimination types of affirmative action are permissible, those that give preference to individuals solely based on their race or gender should not be permitted. Carl Cohen is Professor of Philosophy at the Residential College of the University of Michigan, in Ann Arbor Michigan, USA Cohen also helped find evidence in 1996 through the Freedom of Information Act that lead to the cases filed by Jennifer Gratz and Barbara Grutter against the University of Michigan for its undergraduate and law admissions policy - cases which were decided by the U.S. Supreme Court on June 23, 2003. The Supreme Court of the United States is the highest judicial body in the United States and leads the federal judiciary. Events 1180 - First Battle of Uji, starting the Genpei War in Japan 1305 - The Flemish Year 2003 ( MMIII) was a Common year starting on Wednesday of the Gregorian calendar.

Controversy

Proponents of affirmative action generally advocate it either as a means to address past discrimination or to enhance racial, ethnic, gender, or other diversity of some minority groups. Unlike most discrimination policies discrimination between, which is the discernment of qualities and recognition of the differences focused here discrimination against is The term race or racial group usually refers to the concept of categorizing Humans into Populations or groups on the basis of various sets Gender comprises a range of differences between men and women extending from the biological to the social In the political arena the term diversity (or diverse is used to describe political entities (neighborhoods cities nations student bodies etc [5] They may argue that the end result—a more diversified and representative student body, police force or other group—justifies the means, despite the text of the Equal Protection Clause, and regardless of the adverse discrimination against European Americans or Asian Americans. Consequentialism refers to those moral theories which hold that the consequences of a particular action form the basis for any valid moral judgment about that action The Equal Protection Clause, part of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, provides that "no state shall… deny to any person A European American (Euro-American is a person who resides in the United States and is either from Europe or is the descendant of European immigrants Asian Americans are Americans of Asian ancestry. They include sub-ethnic groups such as Chinese Americans Filipino Americans Indian

Philanthropists have drawn comparisons between the current economic state of some non-dominant groups and poverty. Philanthropy is the act of donating money goods services time and/or effort to support a socially beneficial cause with a defined objective and with no financial or material Poverty (also called penury) is deprivation of common necessities that determine the quality of life including food clothing shelter and safe Drinking water, and Children born, today, to dominant families are clearly not at all responsible for poverty throughout the world. Although these children have in no way caused or condoned poverty, history predicts that some will nevertheless see poverty as an injustice that should be righted if indeed possible. Proponents of affirmative action may believe that genuine residual social and economic injustices continue to affect particular groups; and that these injustices should be righted if indeed possible. JUSTICE is a Human rights and law reform organisation based in the United Kingdom. Beyond the moral arguments for righting injustices, some proponents claim that immediate reparatory action - rather than delayed action or no action – can prevent the social and economic issues from reaching a stage where they become impossible (or greatly more difficult) to repair.

Much of the controversy surrounding affirmative action’s effectiveness is based on the idea of class inequality. Social class refers to the hierarchical distinctions (or stratification) between individuals or groups in Societies or Cultures. Opponents of racial affirmative action argue that the program actually benefits middle and upper class minorities at the expense of lower class whites. This argument supports the idea of solely class based affirmative action. America’s poor is disproportionately made up of minorities, so class based affirmative action would disproportionately help minorities. This would eliminate the need for race based affirmative action as well as reducing any disproportionate benefits for middle and upper class minorities. [6]

Proponents of affirmative action argue that by nature the system is not only race based, but also class and gender based. To eliminate two of its key components would undermine the purpose of the entire system. The African American Policy Forum believes that the class based argument is based on the idea that non-poor minorities do not experience racial and gender based discrimination. Unlike most discrimination policies discrimination between, which is the discernment of qualities and recognition of the differences focused here discrimination against is The AAPF believes that "Race-conscious affirmative action remains necessary to address race-based obstacles that block the path to success of countless people of color of all classes". The groups goes on to say that affirmative action is responsible for creating the African American middle class, so it does not make sense to say that the system only benefits the middle and upper classes. [7]

Opponents further claim that affirmative action has undesirable side-effects and that it fails to achieve its goals. They argue that it factors race into the decision-making process, perpetrates new wrongs to counter old ones, and undermines the achievements of minorities. It may increase racial tension and benefit the more privileged people within minority groups (such as middle to upper-class blacks) at the expense of the disenfranchised within majority groups (such as lower-class whites). In the British 2001 Summer of Violence Riots in Oldham, Bradford, Leeds and Burnley, one of the major complaints voiced in poor white areas was alleged discrimination in council funding which favored minority areas. Oldham is a large town in Greater Manchester, England It lies amongst the Pennines on elevated ground between the rivers Irk and Medlock Bradford ( lies at the heart of the City of Bradford, a Metropolitan borough of West Yorkshire, England. Leeds ( is located on the River Aire in West Yorkshire, England Burnley is a large Market town in the borough of Burnley in Lancashire, England, with a population of around 73500 There has recently been a strong push among American states to ban racial or gender preferences in university admissions, in reaction to the controversial and unprecedented decision in Grutter v. Bollinger. University admission or college admissions is the process through which students enter Tertiary education at universities and Colleges Systems Grutter v Bollinger, 539 US 306 (2003 is a case in which the United States Supreme Court upheld the Affirmative action In 2006, nearly 60% of Michigan voters decided to ban affirmative action in university admissions. Michigan joined California, Florida, Texas, and Washington in banning the use of race or sex in admissions considerations. [8] Some research has indicated that as many as 15 percent of freshmen enrolled at some of America's most selective colleges are wealthy white teens who failed to meet their institutions' minimum admissions standards, furthermore these wealthy white teens outnumber students who benefit from affirmative action. [9]

Some also claim that, in college or professional admissions, it hurts those it intends to help, since it causes a "mismatching" effect by admitting minority students who are less qualified than their peers into more rigorous programs wherein they cannot keep up and eventually fail to gain the degree or pass professional qualification exam (such as Bar exam) UCLA School of Law professor Richard Sander wrote several papers on this occurring in both the law schools, bar exam and in law firms. Mismatching is the term given to the negative effect that Affirmative action has when it places a student into a college that is too difficult for him or her [10]

How the media portray affirmative action and affirmative action cases plays a role in how the public responds to affirmative action. There are claims that the practice is racist or sexist, or both, depending on how one defines those concepts (for instance, the offering of extra college scholarships to black and Hispanic students as opposed to white or Asian students appears overtly racist). List of racism-related topics|Racism by country Racism, by its simplest definition is the belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that Sexism is the belief or attitude that one Gender or Sex is inferior to or less valuable than the other and can also refer to a Hatred or distrust towards African Americans or Black Americans are citizens or residents of the United States who have origins in any of the black populations of Africa Hispanic and Latino Americans are Americans of Hispanic or Latino descent, which comprises ancestry or origins in Hispanic America A European American (Euro-American is a person who resides in the United States and is either from Europe or is the descendant of European immigrants Asian Americans are Americans of Asian ancestry. They include sub-ethnic groups such as Chinese Americans Filipino Americans Indian List of racism-related topics|Racism by country Racism, by its simplest definition is the belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that Others believe that programs may be motivated by political considerations. Politics Politics is the process by which groups of people make decisions

The International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination stipulates (in Article 2. The International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD is a United Nations convention. 2) that affirmative action programs may be required of countries that have ratified the convention, in order to rectify systematic discrimination. It states, however, that such programs "shall in no case entail as a consequence the maintenance of unequal or separate rights for different racial groups after the objectives for which they were taken have been achieved. " The United Nations Human Rights Committee states, "the principle of equality sometimes requires States parties to take affirmative action in order to diminish or eliminate conditions which cause or help to perpetuate discrimination prohibited by the Covenant. For example, in a State where the general conditions of a certain part of the population prevent or impair their enjoyment of human rights, the State should take specific action to correct those conditions. Such action may involve granting for a time to the part of the population concerned certain preferential treatment in specific matters as compared with the rest of the population. However, as long as such action is needed to correct discrimination, in fact, it is a case of legitimate differentiation under the Covenant. "[11]

An in-depth examination of the legal status of affirmative action, as well as the different kinds of programs that exist and their pros and cons, can be found in a paper written for the United Nations Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights by one of its members, Marc Bossuyt. In Law legal status refers to the concept of individuals having a particular place in society relative to the law as it determines the laws which affect them The Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights (before 1999 known as the Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities) was Marc Bossuyt (b Ghent, 9 January 1944) obtained a PhD in law at the University of Ghent in 1968, and a Certificate of international [12]

Implementation worldwide

In some countries which have laws on racial equality, affirmative action is rendered illegal by a requirement to treat all races equally. This approach of equal treatment is sometimes described as being "color blind", in hopes that it is effective against discrimination without engaging in reverse discrimination. Color-blind (sometimes called Race-blind) is a term describing activities undertaken and services provided without regard to the racial characteristics of those who Reverse Discrimination, is in its simplest form the practice of favouring a historically disadvantaged group at the expense of members of a historically advantaged group

In such countries, the focus tends to be on ensuring equal opportunity and, for example, targeted advertising campaigns to encourage ethnic minority candidates to join the police force. This is sometimes described as "positive action" or "positive discrimination".

See main article: Reservation in India
See also: Bumiputra

See also

Notes and references

  1. ^ Public Administration Review[1]
  2. ^ Hopwood v. An achievement gap refers to the observed disparity on a number of Educational measures between the performance of groups of students especially groups defined by Gender Affirmative action in the United States is intended to promote access to education employment or housing among certain designated groups (typically Minorities and Women An affirmative action bake sale is a campus protest event used by student groups to illustrate criticism of Affirmative action policies especially as they relate to College Angry White Male (sometimes abbreviated as AWM is the designation of a Voting bloc of white Males in the United States that came into use during Unlike most discrimination policies discrimination between, which is the discernment of qualities and recognition of the differences focused here discrimination against is Economic discrimination is a term that describes a form of discrimination based on economic factors Employment equity refers to Canadian policies that require or encourage preferential treatment in employment practices for certain designated groups women people with disabilities Aboriginal Jewish quota was a percentage that limited the number of Jews in various establishments The term minority rights embodies two separate concepts first normal individual Rights as applied to members of racial Ethnic, class religious linguistic or The term multiculturalism generally refers to a state of racial, cultural and ethnic diversity within the Demographics of a specified Legacy preferences or legacy admission is a type of preference given by educational institutions to certain applicants on the basis of their familial relationship to Alumni Numerus clausus ("closed number" in Latin) is one of many methods used to limit the number of Students who may study at a University Political correctness (adjectivally politically correct; both forms commonly abbreviated to PC) is a term applied to Language, ideas policies or behavior ||-||} Positive liberty refers to the opportunity and ability to act to fulfill one's own potential as opposed to Negative liberty, which refers to freedom from In Political science, a principle-policy puzzle is a disconnect between support for a principle and support for a policy supporting that principle The Race of the Future Theory / Idea states that due to the process of Miscegenation, the mixing of different ethnicities or races especially in marriage The study of race and intelligence is a controversial field which seeks to determine whether or not human intellectual abilities vary between races The modern controversy In the United States there is inequality between different groups of people. Racism in the United States has been a major issue since the colonial era Reservation in Indian law is a form of Affirmative action whereby a percentage of seats are reserved in the public sector units union and state civil services Reverse Discrimination, is in its simplest form the practice of favouring a historically disadvantaged group at the expense of members of a historically advantaged group Teaching for Social justice is an educational philosophy that proponents argue Teaches for Justice and equity all learners in Texas (pdf)[2]
  3. ^ Sher, George, "Preferential Hiring", in Tom Regan (ed. ), Just Business: New Introductory Essays In Business Ethics, Philadelphia, Temple University Press, 1983, p. 40.
  4. ^ Cameron Huey, "The Curse of the Model Minority" originally published in the Daily Californian, September 5, 2006. The Daily Californian (or Daily Cal) is an independent student-run Newspaper that serves the University of California Berkeley Events 1590 - Alexander Farnese 's army forces Henry IV of France to raise the siege of Paris. Year 2006 ( MMVI) was a Common year starting on Sunday of the Gregorian calendar. http://www.dailycal.org/sharticle.php?id=21236
  5. ^ Richardson, L. Anita. "What is the Constitutional Status of Affirmative Action?: Reading Tea Leaves. " Affirmative Action: a Dialogue on Race, Gender, Equality and Law in America XIII. 2 (1998). 16 November 2006 http://www.abanet.org/publiced/focus/spr98const.html
  6. ^ Hurst, C. Events 534 - A second and final revision of the Codex Justinianus is published Year 2006 ( MMVI) was a Common year starting on Sunday of the Gregorian calendar. Social Inequality: Forms, Causes, and Consequences. Sixth Edition. 2007. 374-377.
  7. ^ 13 Myths About Affirmative Action: A Special Series on a Public Policy Under Siege. African American Policy Forum. Retrieved on 2008-03-03. 2008 ( MMVIII) is the current year in accordance with the Gregorian calendar, a Leap year that started on Tuesday of the Common Events 1284 - Statute of Rhuddlan incorporated the Principality of Wales into England 1575 - Indian
  8. ^ Affirmative action ban draws a challenge. The National Law Journal. Retrieved on 2008-03-03. 2008 ( MMVIII) is the current year in accordance with the Gregorian calendar, a Leap year that started on Tuesday of the Common Events 1284 - Statute of Rhuddlan incorporated the Principality of Wales into England 1575 - Indian
  9. ^ At the elite colleges - dim white kids By Peter Schmidt. September 28, 2007. Events 48 BC - Pompey the Great is assassinated on orders of King Ptolemy of Egypt after landing in Egypt. Year 2007 ( MMVII) was a Common year starting on Monday of the Gregorian calendar in the 21st century. The Boston Globe. The Boston Globe (and Boston Sunday Globe) is the most widely circulated daily Newspaper in Boston and in New England,
  10. ^ Sander, Richard H. . Research Areas and Publications. University of California - Los Angeles. The University of California Los Angeles (generally known as UCLA) is a public research university located in Westwood Los Angeles, California, United Retrieved on 2008-03-03. 2008 ( MMVIII) is the current year in accordance with the Gregorian calendar, a Leap year that started on Tuesday of the Common Events 1284 - Statute of Rhuddlan incorporated the Principality of Wales into England 1575 - Indian
  11. ^ United Nations Committee on Human Rights, General Comment 18 on Non-discrimination, Paragraph 10
  12. ^ United Nations Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights. Commission on Human Rights, Economic and Social Council, 17 June 2002
  13. ^ Plummer, Robert. Events 1462 - Vlad III the Impaler attempts to assassinate Mehmed II ( The Night Attack) forcing him to retreat See also 2002 (disambiguation Year 2002 ( MMII) was a Common year starting on Tuesday of the Gregorian calendar. "Black Brazil Seeks a Better Future. " BBC News, São Paulo 25 September 2006. Events 303 - On a voyage preaching the Gospel, Saint Fermin of Pamplona is beheaded in Amiens, France Year 2006 ( MMVI) was a Common year starting on Sunday of the Gregorian calendar. 16 November 2006 <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/5357842.stm>. Events 534 - A second and final revision of the Codex Justinianus is published Year 2006 ( MMVI) was a Common year starting on Sunday of the Gregorian calendar.
  14. ^ GNWT - Human Resources - Affirmative Action <http://www.hr.gov.nt.ca/employment/affirmativeaction/>
  15. ^ Bumiputra Policy in Malaysia
  16. ^ a b c UK Commission for Racial Equality website "Affirmative action around the world" http://www.cre.gov.uk/Default.aspx.LocID-0hgnew0l0.RefLocID-0hg01b001006009.Lang-EN.htm
  17. ^ Simon Wood meets the people who lost most when Mandela won in South Africa
  18. ^ Personneltoday. The Commission for Racial Equality (CRE was a Non-departmental public body in the United Kingdom which aimed to tackle Racial discrimination and promote com "Is there a case for positive discrimination?" http://www.personneltoday.com/Articles/2006/01/17/33430/is-there-a-case-for-positive-discrimination.html
  19. ^ BBC News "Police recruitment 'will be 50:50'" 12 September 2001 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/1540861.stm
  20. ^ Indy fire-fighters sue city, charge bias

External links

Events 1213 - Albigensian Crusade: Simon de Montfort 5th Earl of Leicester, defeats Peter II of Aragon at the Year 2001 ( MMI) was a Common year starting on Monday according to the Gregorian calendar.

Dictionary

affirmative action

-noun

  1. A policy or program providing advantages for people of a minority group who are seen to have traditionally been discriminated against, with the aim of creating a more egalitarian society through preferential access to education, employment, health care, social welfare, etc.
© 2009 citizendia.org; parts available under the terms of GNU Free Documentation License, from http://en.wikipedia.org